The American crayfish, accidentally introduced in the 1960s, has thrived so successfully in Lake Annecy that it has wiped out all the local crayfish species.

Every year, nearly three tonnes are fished out, yet this has done nothing to curb a species classed as invasive and carrying a disease that is deadly to its native cousins.

Three tonnes fished out every year, yet no decline

In the waters of Lake Annecy, the American crayfish is everywhere, particularly along the rocky eastern shore near Talloires. The lake's last two professional fishermen catch around three tonnes of it a year. An impressive volume, yet not enough to dislodge it. Introduced by humans in the 1960s, it originally came from California and is recognisable by the orange underside of its legs and its bluish sheen.

A killer that never falls ill

Its real weapon is invisible. The American crayfish is a healthy carrier of crayfish plague, as Yann Magnani, chairman of the lake's fishing association, points out. The disease does it no harm, but it is devastating for local crayfish, which are far more vulnerable to it. In other words, the newcomer doesn't even need to fight: its mere presence is enough to permanently contaminate the environment.

Continues after this ad

Local crayfish have vanished from the lake

This crayfish, photographed in the United States, illustrates the American species now colonising Lake Annecy.
This crayfish, photographed in the United States, illustrates the American species now colonising Lake Annecy.© Brian Forsyth

The result speaks for itself. The white-clawed crayfish, the red-clawed crayfish and the stone crayfish have completely disappeared from the waters of Lake Annecy. They still survive in some watercourses in Haute-Savoie, where the fishing federation has been monitoring their populations for twenty-three years.

These species act as a barometer: as long as they're present, the river is in good health. In the nearby Fier river, the American crayfish is already tending to wipe out its rivals.

Anglers on alert: what the law says

Faced with the invasion, the rule is clear. Fishing for American crayfish is permitted all year round with a fishing licence, with no minimum size or quota. Amateurs are not allowed to release it or transport it alive: it must be killed before being moved.

Only professionals using traps are permitted to transport it alive to fishmongers and restaurants on an official prefectural list.

Seeing Lake Annecy in a different light

This story does nothing to diminish the beauty of the place, but it says a great deal about how fragile an ecosystem can be. On a trip to the water's edge, a stop at a fisherman's stall can sometimes teach you more than a guidebook. To enjoy the lake with the family, our nature walk ideas and our canoeing and kayaking recommendations offer plenty of ways to explore the shoreline differently, crayfish lurking discreetly beneath the surface.

Continues after this ad

Ruler of a territory that was never its own, the American crayfish is a reminder that a released species never leaves. And that even the most beautiful of lakes is not immune.